Ripstein Made

 Im on the plane :D 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

I Love Internal Goods

I really liked MacIntyre when we first read him. I really really like MacIntyre after reading Blackburn. Blackburn makes a key distinction between empirical and theoretical situations to better understand the priorities/concerns of an agent making a utility-maximizing decision. Empirical situations look at the outcomes of what will empirically result from a given decision. I may choose option A over B, because I will earn $100 in option A and I will be imprisoned for 5 years in option B. As someone who values money over imprisonment, Option A has higher utility to me based on the empirical results. Theoretical situations factor in priorities/concerns that are not tied to the empirical results of a decision to more fully explain the decision-making process. I may choose option B over A because I enjoy the activity of option B, or I know the $100 reward for option A was stolen from a poor family.  I find it helpful—and relevant—to characterize empirical situations as considering MacI...
Read more

Trump, Visas, and Blackburn on why more than exit costs are important

I did spend a large part of the tutorial arguing that lowering exit costs would be almost enough to increase accountability of firms to the point that they can not act arbitrarily, otherwise they would lose their workers. After reading Anderson's response to Cowen, my thoughts have developed a little bit more. Anderson's response to Cowen's argument surrounding lowering exit costs argues that lowering exit costs doesn't matter if there is nowhere to exit to (141). I think there is an argument to go a step further, that even when there is a place to exit to, quitting and/or being fired arbitrarily is suboptimal for everyone.  Take the current Administration's revoking of students' statuses as Anderson's exile analogy of being fired. I'm choosing to focus on students because they often have low costs of exit, they (often) aren't in the country with refugee or other asylum status, can pivot and get an education somewhere else, and are leaving their frie...
Read more

Being A Government Official Sucks

This post forwards a concern I have external to Shiffrin’s argument, but relevant when considering the implications of how she proposes government officials should communicate with the public.  Shiffrin holds government officials (speaking in their capacity as government officials) to a higher standard in their speech than citizens. In one example of this higher standard, she argues that government officials seeking to criticize the Constitution or how citizens exercise rights must either “not speak in their capacity as governmental officials” or, if they do, “make clear what the extant protection is” with a (non-“fine print,” “rubber-stamped”) disclaimer (1004). She recognizes this imbalance in responsibility, reaffirming that “this requirement does burden the speech of government officials with higher standards than lay citizens, but that heightened burden is consistent with the special role of government officials” (1005). Can we not burden government officials to the point wher...
Read more